Source :
Philequity Corner (March 1, 2010)
By Valentino Sy
The Stable Philippine Peso
Despite problems in the Eurozone, the weakness of the Euro and the general recovery in the US
dollar, the Philippine peso remains one of the most stable currencies in the world. Year-to-date
the peso barely moved at 46.13 against the US dollar, slightly weaker by -0.07 percent.
Other Asian currencies, likewise, performed relatively well against the US dollar (see table). In
fact, the currencies of our ASEAN neighbors such as Thailand, Indonesia and Malaysia have
appreciated this year against the greenback.
Current Price YTD Chg (%)
Philippine Peso 46.1300 -0.07
Major Currencies
Japanese Yen 88.9670 4.51
Australian Dollar 0.8954 -0.23
Canadian Dollar 1.0518 -0.27
Swiss Franc 1.0735 -3.51
Euro 1.3632 -4.85
British Pound 1.5238 -5.77
European Currencies
Russian Ruble 29.9480 -0.19
Czech Koruna 19.0710 -4.09
Slovakia Koruna 22.1060 -5.69
Danish Krone 5.4608 -5.70
Hungarian Forint 197.9500 -6.16
Turkish Lira 1.5445 -35.07
Latin American Currencies
Mexican Peso 12.7720 2.07
Chilean Peso 524.5500 -5.28
Brazil Real 1.8076 -5.33
Venezuelan Bolivar 4.2946 -50.00
Asian Currencies
Thai Baht 33.0600 4.22
Indonesian Rupiah 9 ,342.5000 1.47
Malaysian Ringgit 3.4028 1.14
Indian Rupee 46.0850 0.96
Chinese Yuan 6.8260 0.02
Philippine Peso 46.1300 -0.07
Singapore Dollar 1.4064 -0.10
South Korean Won 1 ,159.8500 -0.15
Taiwan Dollar 32.0720 -0.25
Source: Bloomberg
In contrast, the Euro has depreciated by -4.85 percent against the US dollar year-to-date.
Meanwhile, the British pound and the Swiss Franc are weaker by -5.77 percent and -3.51 percent,
respectively. The worst performers are the Venezuelan Bolivar which devalued by -50 percent
and the Turkish Lira which weakened by -35 percent.
Peso is holding despite Euro weakness
In our article last week (see The “IPIS” Theory), we mentioned that we are looking closely at the
Euro which is weakening because of the debt problems in the Eurozone. We said the US dollar
generally looks bullish. Therefore the peso would probably weaken to 48 in the middle part of
the year before rebounding back towards the 45 to 46 levels by year-end when the bulk of the
remittance money comes in.
Note, however, that despite the weakness of the Euro, the peso and other Asian currencies appear
to be holding. If the Euro finds support at 1.28 and turns, then Asian currencies may actually
appreciate and the peso may go back to the 45 levels much earlier than we expect.
Reasons for the peso strength
We believe that the peso will remain relatively strong despite the volatility emanating from the
Eurozone because of the following reasons:
1) Record OFW remittances – Remittances in December 2009 surged 11.4 percent to a new
monthly high of $1.567 billion. This surpassed the previous record of $1.531 billion registered in
October 2009 (during the aftermath of Typhoon Ondoy). For the whole 2009, remittances
increased 5.4 percent to a record high of $17.348 billion. This exceeded the 4 percent target set
by the BSP for the year.
2) Increased portfolio inflows to the stock market – There has also been a substantial increase
in portfolio inflows to the stock market in recent weeks. Net foreign buying registered by the
PSE in February amounted to Php3 billion. This figure is significantly larger than the Php1.28
billion net inflow registered in January and the monthly average of Php1.24 billion in 2009.
3) Creation of a Philippine Exchange Traded Fund (ETF) – Another reason for the increased
foreign buying in Philippine stocks is the possible creation of a Philippine ETF. ETF.com
reported that iShares recently filed with the SEC an iShares MSCI Philippines Investable Market
Index Fund. This may be the reason why big caps have staged a strong rebound despite the concerns on Greece’s debt and China’s monetary tightening. It now appears that the 2,800 support for the
PSE index which we mentioned in a previous article has held (see Bulaga! in the January 2`5,
2010 issue of The Philippine Star).
4) Resumption of export growth – Last December, Philippine exports rose the fastest in four
years. Exports of electronics, which make up more than half of our exports, expanded 40.9
percent. Overall, exports grew almost 25 percent as the global economy recovered.
Possible risks to our forecast
At the same time, we have to watch out for certain risks that may affect our “stable” peso
forecast. We are concerned about the following:
1) Widening of fiscal deficit – Officially, the government has set a budget deficit of Php293
billion for 2010. We just have to watch out for our fiscal deficit or suffer the same fate as those
in the Eurozone. Selling assets are just stop-gap measures.
2) Steep rise in commodity prices – The peso will also be negatively affected if the price of oil
goes above $100 per barrel again or rough rice goes back to record price levels.
3) Failure of elections – Lastly, we cannot discount a failure of elections in May or an election
result without a clear-cut winner.
In defense of the BSP
Last week, members of the Philippine Exporters Confederation, Inc. (Philexport) passed a
resolution formally asking the BSP “to start re-thinking its exchange rate policy that has equated
to a strong peso.” They said that it is “hurting domestic industries, overseas Filipino workers and
exports.”
We just like to point out that, contrary to their allegation, the BSP has in fact defended the dollar
against a strong peso several times when it broke the 46 level in the past. If the BSP did not
intervene back then, the peso would have broken even the 45 level. Currently, the BSP adheres to a market-oriented foreign exchange policy, but at the same time, it ensures orderly conditions in the market. We believe the BSP will intervene if the peso aggressively strengthens to 45, just like they did back in the past. And they will also be there to defend the peso if it depreciates to 48 to 49. Peso may reach 43
Despite the risks mentioned above, there is a good chance that the peso may breach the BSP’s
target range of 45 to 49. The possible catalysts for the peso to go beyond the BSP band are the
following:
1) The election results in a widely accepted new government.
2) A new government that will take the bull by its horns by addressing the fiscal deficit
directly (e.g. the standardization of sin taxes, scrapping of superfluous tax incentives,
curtailment of smuggling, a rise in tax collections and an increase in VAT from 12
percent to 15 percent).
3) A resumption of the bull trend in emerging markets, particularly Asia, which will be
positive for Asian currencies.
4) A breakout in the PSE Index above the previous high of 3,133.53 and the resumption of
the bullish trend in the Philippine stock market.
5) A sustainable recovery in exports, a remarkable increase in tourism, and a dramatic rise
in remittances.
If these catalysts materialize, we may have to change our forecast for the peso. If the PSE index
goes to 3,300 and the S&P 500 goes to 1,250, that may mean that the peso will move towards the
43 level.
For comments and inquiries, you can email us at
info@philequity.net. You can also view our
archived articles at
Philequity Management, Inc. or
www.wealthsec.com.