the VS. thread

[DrE]

---

based on the COMIC, not movie, tv series or cartoon, who would win in a fight? state your reasons.

1) batman vs. daredevil

[gareb]

daredevil.

reason: batman is just too HUMAN. frail. weak. and he depends on him bat-gadgetry too much. he is basically crap without em.

daredevil is way too cool for him.

[Carlo Borromeo]

I deleted this one and...

[Carlo Borromeo]

reason: batman is just too HUMAN. frail. weak. and he depends on him bat-gadgetry too much. he is basically crap without em.

You're basing your opinion about his "gadgetry" on the movie and cartoons.

In the comics, he's a world-class detective who has dedicated his life to fighting crime since he was 8 years old. He's proficient in several martial arts, while Daredevil only knows 1 (ninjitsu).

And don't forget, DD is blind as a (hehehe) bat.

[patrixxx73]

based on the COMIC, not movie, tv series or cartoon, who would win in a fight? state your reasons.

1) batman vs. daredevil

Batman the most obsessive crime-fighter in comics. His training was, undoubtedly, much broader in scope that Daredevil's.

COMBAT EXPERIENCE/TACTICAL ABILITY -- both of these guys have fought thousands of opponents in every kind of fistfight situation imaginable, from normal thug to huge hulking goon (Kingpin, Bane, etc.) to ultra-juiced cyber-killers to mutated monsters to God knows what. They've fought on rooftops, mountainsides, city streets, alleys, sewer tunnels, you name it. As far as hand-to-hand melee goes, there isn't hardly anything either of these guys hasn't experienced before at least once. But while the stuff listed above is about just the limit of Daredevil's experience, it doesn't even begin to touch Batman's range of experience.



WILLPOWER -- you want either of these guys to stop coming at you, shoot him. With an artillery barrage. Twice. That's about the only way you're going to do it. Advantage -- even. So my take on the fight is that Daredevil gives Batman one of his world-class fights,(but Batman despite taking early damage) is keeping up the whole way... and then Batman figures out that Daredevil is blind. And then he figures that the man has hyper-developed his senses to compensate. (He's a detective, he can deduce this. He can out-deduce Sherlock Holmes.) And then Batman switches over to sensory overload attacks, He'll probably use percussion caps to mess with his hearing, stun or CS gas to interfere with his smell, and toss a couple of Batarangs to mess with that radar of Daredevil's. While Daredevil is trying to recover from that, Batman picks him apart with a powerful combination of his martial art skills. And then Daredevil goes down.

Batman wins!

[zerk]

batman.... daredevil is a batman rip-off without the cape. head-on dd might stand a chance but if bats sets the stage. bats wins

[blade101]

I totally agree with patrixxx- what batman lacks, he makes up for his ability to think fast on his feet and street smarts. batman is one of those heroes who wouldn't have problems fighting dirty(although I prefer to call it fighting smart). DD may win the first few scuffles but the when bats figures out a way to circumvent DD's so so radar-like abilites, the match will be over by then.

[EZRA]

Batsmans will win kay naa man si Robin mo ambit..

[gareb]

a big if.

daredevil is known for his quick reflexes.. even before batman can deduce of his weakness and make an impressive display of his gadgetry moolah, DD would have did his share of ass kicking already.

i dunno guys. call be biased. i just hate, batman thats all. not because he has no 'super-powers' its the way he handles himself. cock and bull style. mystery behind the caped crusader. ugh. too old skool.

[Carlo Borromeo]

i dunno guys. call be biased. i just hate, batman thats all. not because he has no 'super-powers' its the way he handles himself. cock and bull style. mystery behind the caped crusader. ugh. too old skool.

And what are you basing this opinion on?

How many Batman books have you read?

Do you know that there's not a single Batman movie that has done the comics justice?

And Daredevil is a rip-off of Batman.