depende sad sa imo gusto...
if you are after the beach + heritage tour, then bantayan is definitely the right choice
if you are after the beach + diving + snorkeling, malapascua's the one..
Some very helpful tips:
1. Stable ang water and electricity supply sa bantayan kaysa malapascua.
2. Mas kuyaw ang Malapascua during "habagat season" - kusog kaayu ang waves ug current unya chances pa gyud ma stranded kay i cancel sa mga pumpboat operators ang byahe without notice..
3. Bring nalang gyud water ug paypay sa malapascua kay inig 12midnight - 2 am
usually total darkness na.. + extra money.