akong gi use karon kay maybelline mani, nindot sad, its really easy to apply, it comes with a brush sad, i use it mainly for my upper lid kay i dont look like i have eyes when im not wearing any, and mao nalang sad ako i-use for my waterline.. di jud cya mo smear. which is good. my cousin has really oily eyelids and pirmi cya mag luha, pencil iyang gamit na waterproof but mo smear jud, but when she used the gel liner it stayed on the whole day, wala ni smear, no need for retouch whatever..